I am simulating a pipe. I have made two identical pipes using extrude and the other one using revolve.
But Inventor is giving me different results on the stress analysis. why is that? which one will I choose?
Regards
|
|
|
I am simulating a pipe. I have made two identical pipes using extrude and the other one using revolve.
But Inventor is giving me different results on the stress analysis. why is that? which one will I choose?
Regards
Post the files here.
How much is the difference in the results.
Different methods of creation will cause the mesh routine to mesh the part differently - but if meshed correctly any difference in results should be statistically insignificant.
For axial deflection
Revolve: 0.08709mm
Extrude: 0.08698mm
Are there any points I should remember to attain a correct mesh?
Regards
I haven't even opened the files yet, but you should realize that those two numbes are essentially identical.