Detail Component line based vs. Repeating detail

[dbaldacchino]

I'm trying to figure out in what situations I'd want to do this family or use the repeating detail tool. From what I understand, the detail component line-based family can do exactly the same thing that the repeating detail tool can, correct? So why would I want to use it? Thanks.

[Steve_Stafford]

The repeating detail feature will involve less effort on your part since it just uses a detail component that you've already built. The line based detail components work better for things like plywood or gwb sections that don't have regular breaks or intervals. The repeating detail is better for those...just some thoughts.

[Arnel Aguel]

Thanks Steve for your thought, I've been wondering these two families too for quite sometime as it seems that they serve the same purpose aside from few examples you mentioned.

[modulor]

Repeating detail only works with 2D 'detail components'.
Line-based families allow repeating model components, like rafters or parking spaces.
check out www.revitfamilyman.com for examples.

Erik

[Steve_Stafford]

Repeating detail only works with 2D 'detail components'.
Line-based families allow repeating model components, like rafters or parking spaces.
check out www.revitfamilyman.com for examples.

Erik

There are two line based family templates, one for detail components and one for generic model. I assumed David was most curious about the application of the detail component version for comparison sake, fwiw...

[dbaldacchino]

You're correct Steve, my question is regarding the detail component line based family. The Generic Model line based has a ton of applications. The Detail component line based is view-specific, just like the repeating detail. I guess the main difference is that you can "stretch" things in the D.C. line based family, while with the repeating detail tool you cannot.

[Revitator]

PMFJI, but the line-based family does seem to give you more flexibility than the repeating detail. You can embed several different arrays of detail components within one line-based family, and you can constrain other geometry to the two endpoints. So you can make a line-based component with arrays and lines-that-stretch in the middle, and 'finials' at either end.

I've attached a little test family. The array, box and lines flex with the Length parameter, while the finial circles remain attached to the ends of the component. I'm sure someone can come up with a more practical example.

[dbaldacchino]

Thanks for the reply. Yes that clearly explains the differences/possibilities between the two. For things that repeat at the same intervals, such as coursing joints in section for instance, the repeating detail command is just as good and quicker than using the line based family. This example clearly illustartes what cannot be done with the R.D. tool.

[Steve_Stafford]

In my earlier reply when I said, "less effort" I was really saying, "without getting into the family editor and arrays" etc. The line based family has much more potential than the Repeating Detail feature.

[dbaldacchino]

...and I have not gotten into arrays yet, so I wasn't aware of a major benefit of that family. I have seen arrays in louver familes etc., but never used them myself yet.