PDA

View Full Version : 2017 Inconsistency with Parameter-Driven Arc placement in Family



ronsai
2017-03-21, 06:38 PM
Does anyone have any idea what's going on here?

I have a family with a few parameter driven dimensions - see screenshots. The family is essentially to represent some cable hanging between two fixed points at various spans with varying amounts of sag (a circular curve approximates a catenary close enough for my purposes). The sag parameter is a % value of the span and controls the position of the center point for the arc and the radius of the arc. The end points of the arc are aligned to the horizontal reference line.

The parameters and geometry all work together fine at 10% as in the following example:

104903

When I change the sag to 5%, everything still works:

104904

When I change the sag to 2%, the arc decides to flip around and go the other way:

104905

And of course when I change it back to the original 10%, it keeps the incorrect geometry:

104906

How on earth do I make Revit understand? And to make it more maddening, if I incrementally step the value down by 1 and apply it each time, it keeps the geometry correct, but if I change it straight from 5% to 2% it flips.

gsucci
2017-06-26, 09:31 AM
Any follow up on this?

It happens often and is just making people waste a lot of time.

Thanks

Gio

Dimitri Harvalias
2017-06-26, 02:37 PM
I'm not in front of a computer all day to test but try creating the arc as a three point arc with the mid point controlled by a ref line.