Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 11 to 17 of 17

Thread: Calling all! educators - What do you teach

  1. #11
    Active Member
    Join Date
    2005-09
    Location
    San Francisco Bay Area
    Posts
    93
    Login to Give a bone
    0

    Default Re: Calling all! educators - What do you teach

    Hi Clyne,
    Nice to see a full time educator here.
    I'm not a bimmer yet. Just learning and trying to apply it to my office.
    Vanilla Autocad 2004 (but with my own custom menu's etc). I used to teach autocad at a junior college but with it's application as an architectural tool. So how we coordinate with consultants, layering structure, proper x-referencing and cad standards. Plus I would throw in an intro to 3D Max and modeling in autocad. (contrary to popular believe, it's never too much to do in one semester). The point was to create students who would be productive in an architectural office, be flexible enough to adapt to that firms' standards. This being a junior college, and their first semester using cad. I placed half the class for summer intern jobs. The rest were transferring to 4 yr uni's.

    I'm glad to see that you're cutting edge and pushing your students.
    It is a good idea that enables a student to see how it all goes together. Constructing a model as opposed to just modeling (i.e building a cardboard model or using regular 3D)
    I gather that yours is a design class but uses Revit as a modeling/ design tool? Actually this is nice to see. Taking Revit beyond just a drafting class. I can see why it's so popular. Sometimes I feel the students are way ahead in technology and just waitting for the appropriate courses to come along.

    That being said, I know that some educators feel that students have their whole life's ahead of them in the working arena to learn the professional aspects of their work life. I.e. professional practise, working with consultants, contracts etc. So design is paramount.
    Yet, those in the field get new grads every year who wished they had learned some of these aspects while in college, so they did not have to struggle as much.


    Do you know if there are other lecturers teaching Revit in a professional practise class? That is get them to start thinking about what it will be like to apply Revit in an office environment. Learning to collaborate and coordinate with team members and MEPs/ structural consultants?

    You brought up a good point about CAD classes. Maybe some of us have been looking at this in too much of a traditional way. CAD classes where we expect students to learn the tools and be able to function in a professional environment.
    Maybe students start out with CAD classes to learn the basics of the tool and then progresss to their professional practise/ working drawings class where they learn how CAD/BIM is used to intergrate a design among the AEC team members. Bring up CAD standards there. Something that can be achieved in a 4-5yr program. But not really in a vocational school/ junior college program.

    What are your thoughts?
    We're hoping this thread or forum can serve as a way to cross pollinate. Between educators and those in the field. In a constructive way. So I apologize ahead of time if I write anything that may appear offensive.
    Please share your ideas. Again, I do think that your Revit as a design tool is a very good idea. Applying Revit as a computer aided design tool. Maybe because the technology has reached the point where it can be used as such. There are other design studios that use Form-Z, archicad etc.

    Maybe some of the ideas of team collaboration could be utilized in design exercises that require a team of students to share a design and work within workset/workgroups in Revit??
    You probably are doing this already.

  2. #12
    Member stefan.boeykens's Avatar
    Join Date
    2004-11
    Location
    A castle in Belgium
    Posts
    18
    Login to Give a bone
    0

    Default Re: Calling all! educators - What do you teach

    We teach SketchUp, AutoCAD, Photoshop, Flash, ADT, VIZ Render, Illustrator, Acrobat... more or less in that order.
    This is for students of architecture (faculty of engineering).

    We were totally AutoCAD based, but I introduced SketchUp and will introduce BIM in the curriculum. I am inclined to switch to Revit or ArchiCAD, though, and skip ADT...
    I still think that a basis of AutoCAD (2D and some 3D) is beneficial for the students. Even if they don't use AutoCAD in practice (many still do), it'll help since everyone needs to exchange AutoCAD files sooner or later...

    In Belgium, most architects use AutoCAD 2D and VectorWorks, although ArchiCAD, ADT, Microstation and recently Revit are being used more and more.

  3. #13
    Active Member
    Join Date
    2005-09
    Location
    San Francisco Bay Area
    Posts
    93
    Login to Give a bone
    0

    Default Re: Calling all! educators - What do you teach

    Hi Stefan,
    So are those programs used as a design tool or as a drafting tool?
    What is your universities approach to it?
    What type of industry standards are introduced to students? Obviously what's done in Belgium will be different than in the states. I'm curious to know.
    Thanks for posting.

  4. #14
    Active Member
    Join Date
    2005-09
    Location
    San Francisco Bay Area
    Posts
    93
    Login to Give a bone
    0

    Default Re: Calling all! educators - What do you teach

    Oh, your signature is impressive. That's a lot of programs to juggle and teach.

  5. #15
    Member stefan.boeykens's Avatar
    Join Date
    2004-11
    Location
    A castle in Belgium
    Posts
    18
    Login to Give a bone
    0

    Default Re: Calling all! educators - What do you teach

    Our syllabus is online. It's partly inside a closed community (using the BlackBoard system at our university, but that requires a student or staff ID) and partly on our own server, which is open. We keep the manuals grouped (independent of the exercises) and then use them throughout the different course programmes.

    It was purely AutoCAD based in the past (and a little bit of VIZ).

    I added SketchUp into the mix and we also extended the presentation assignments (partly digital/web and partly for printwork).

    We don't aim to have a course that fully prepares them for professional work in an architects office, since that is quite narrow focused, from our designer's point of view.

    We rather want to introduce them to several techniques and approaches for the use of computers in architectural design. The CAAD courses are connected to the design studio assignments and to the course of design methodology.

    And the signature... well, it's a hobby to keep looking at several applications. I am an avid ArchiCAD and SketchUp user, but also teach AutoCAD and VIZ. And I recently bought a Mac Portable, to get to know the other side more in detail. I do research and programming (next to my CAAd teaching).

    Some links:
    Our new page with manuals and student homepages (where they can display their assignments):
    http://students.asro.kuleuven.be/new_menu.phtml

    What is still missing is the text on Building Information Modelling, which I will teach in the beginning of next year. I plan to give a generic overview and add short step-by-step examples from ADT, Revit and ArchiCAD in the mix. Expect it to be online somewhere in february.

    An older page of mine, where I export a CAD model (made in ArchiCAD ) into several rendering applications to have some technical comparison of the conversion process and some insight in rendering capabilities.
    http://www2.asro.kuleuven.ac.be/asro...der/render.htm

    And one of my most popular efforts (which is getting dated now):
    a searchable database of CAD and 3D-applications:
    http://www2.asro.kuleuven.ac.be/asro...cad/search.asp

    I plan to update the database in the course of my PhD research, later on this (or next) year.

  6. #16
    Design Visualization Moderator stusic's Avatar
    Join Date
    2004-10
    Location
    Denver, Colorado
    Posts
    1,515
    Login to Give a bone
    0

    Cool Re: Calling all! educators - What do you teach

    Hey All,

    I've been reading the previous posts and want to share some thoughts of mine. I've been using AutoCAD since 1996 when I sat at my uncle's house in Connecticut playing around with Release 12. He is an industrial designer of some flavor and this cool new program sparked my interest. I learned quite a bit in those couple years and even did some work with him on some 3D design projects.

    Well, after returning to Macon, Georgia, I continued to use AutoCAD at a job I found and decided to enroll in AutoCAD classes at our local tech school. It was very disappointing. I don't believe I really learned anything; on the very first day I was looking for some practice work, so I found a couple of models that we were to lay out, dimension, etc... Well, come to find out those were the drawings we were to do for the final-- and here I was with them modeled in 3D, laid out and ready for print on the first day. After that incident, I got out of doing my work by completing a rendering my instructor was to do. This got me wondering how you could learn what you need to know to function in the "real world" as a drafter and not have to be in school for six years...

    To teach a CADD course is going to compromise something just because you have a limited amount of time with your students. I know you can cram a lot of information into a student's sponge of a brain, but with the numerous CAD programs and the varieties of discipline paths they could choose to lead their career, its hard to find a balance between in-depth learning to make them ready for the office and generic teaching to leave them career options. With as much knowledge and experience as it takes to master AutoCAD, how can you even begin to teach a discipline? Or design standards? I've been using AutoCAD for almost 10 years now and I still don't know anything.

    My tech school now teaches AutoCAD, Inventor and 3DS Max. I think it's great they're expanding the curriculum, but I have to ask myself, "How much are these students really learning?" If you learn the basics of AutoCAD and Inventor, you may have choices as far as what programs you'll be looking to use when finding a job, but you're not going to be as proficient as you could be if you just learned one program. And I wouldn't even worry about teaching CAD standards; I have never worked for any firm that used the same standards as another firm. Never. And since the National CAD Standards are still being revised, I don't think its appropriate to be teaching something that's going to be obsolete by the time they graduate.

    As a former student, briefly a CAD instructor and as a working CAD Operator, I think it would be most beneficial for the student to learn one program at a time (that's just my opinion) and learn the skills they are going to need in the local job market. Sure, learn polylines, learn what extrusion is, but also learn to properly plot and scale a drawing. Learn to use xrefs. Learn about coordination between disciplines.

    I'm tired of rambling, but those are my thoughts. It's a fine line to walk; balancing knowledge and marketability.

    Thanks,

    Phillip

  7. #17
    Active Member
    Join Date
    2005-09
    Location
    San Francisco Bay Area
    Posts
    93
    Login to Give a bone
    0

    Default Re: Calling all! educators - What do you teach

    I guess it's not so much an attempt to try to teach students everything there is to know about cad. If you check out Stefan's web sites, it's mainly using the tool as a design tool. But they get to learn how to use different programs as part of it.
    I know many universities are doing that now.
    The difference is that in the field many people expect schools to teach them cad standards. I agree that different firms and AEC disciplines do tend to use the programs differently and all have their own standards. There tends to be some commonality though. The use of x-refs, blocks, layers, layouts (vs. sheet files) etc. Yet not everyone uses them the same and not everyone agrees on how to use them.
    So in a way I do agree that universities cannot be expected to teach cad standards since even the different industries do not have a common standard to teach against.
    But the tools can be provided that they are aware of these standards and the basic tools used or necessary for these standards to function.
    At least they are learning.
    Given many caddies learned the way you did or similarly. But the market is changing and so are the software. What worked in the past may not correlate with how the future is going to be. If we can even anticipate what's going to be the project delivery method of the future.
    But what is interesting is that we all have similar and yet differing ideas of what education can and will do for CAD.
    Heck, just reading through Stefan's web pages was a lot of fun for me.

Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12

Similar Threads

  1. Replies: 0
    Last Post: 2013-05-05, 02:37 AM
  2. Possible to teach yourself Revit?
    By Manter in forum Training
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 2013-01-30, 07:30 PM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •